DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
Division of Transportation Solutions
PROPOSED
PUBLIC NOTICE
2407 Alternative Dispute Resolution Process for Acquisition of Certain Real Property Interests
Background
The Delaware Department of Transportation is seeking public comment regarding an alternative dispute resolution procedure to assist in reaching or finally determine the amount of compensation to be paid for the acquisition of real property, when the Department has filed a condemnation action for that acquisition, in the manner otherwise prescribed by 10 Del.C. Ch. 61.
In some instances, the parties involved may find it useful to engage in either a binding or non-binding review of their respective property valuations, using a panel of qualified appraisers for the purpose. The protocols for this alternative dispute resolution mechanism are outlined in the draft regulations.
Public Comment Period
The Department will take written comments on the proposed Regulation for this Alternative Dispute Resolution Protocol for Acquisition of Certain Real Property Interests from January 1, 2015 through January 31, 2015. The proposed Regulation appears below.
Any requests for copies of the proposed Regulations, or any questions or comments regarding this document should be directed to:
Robert Cunningham
Chief of Right of Way
Division of Transportation Solutions
Delaware Department of Transportation
P.O. Box 778
Dover, DE 19903
(302) 760-2303 (telephone)
(302) 739-2895 (fax)
robert.cunningham3@state.de.us
2407 Alternative Dispute Resolution Process for Acquisition of Certain Real Property
The Department may initiate an Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) process, at the discretion of the Chief Engineer, on a per project basis to provide a property owner the opportunity to initiate and/or agree to a binding or non-binding review to determine the Just Compensation for the acquisition. This review will be held in an attempt to amicably settle the case without going to a formal court hearing. The results of this review will be either binding or non-binding on either party as they may agree in writing. If non-binding, either party can request the case proceed thereafter to a formal hearing. The results of the non-binding review will be considered privileged information and any part of the review, including value conclusions shall not be admissible in any future valuation hearings by either party.
2.1 Both parties must agree to the ADR and the process listed below. Any changes to the process must be approved by both parties and a DAG assigned to the case.
2.2 The ADR review can only take place after an Order for Possession has occurred. However, an agreement to proceed to an ADR is allowed at anytime prior to the Order for Possession.
2.3 Expenses related to the conducting of the ADR review shall be borne by DelDOT, except for any cost incurred by the defendant, their attorney or witnesses in preparing or presenting their case.
2.4 No discovery other than the transfer of appraisals, engineering reports or other documentation typically available during negotiations is allowed.
2.5 All information related to the case shall be held as confidential in the non-binding ADR.
3.1 Upon the entering of an Order for Possession by the Courts, either party (DelDOT or the owner, or their respective representatives) may request an ADR review. This request must be in writing and may be submitted any time after the initiation of negotiations, but no later than within 45 days of the Order for Possession.
3.2 A response to the ADR request must be sent to the requesting party within 15 days of receipt of the request. Non-response by the party receiving the request within the 15 day period shall be construed as a refusal to the request for an ADR review.
3.3 All ADR requests or responses to a request made to DelDOT, or activities/determinations performed by DelDOT as part of the review process must have approval of the Assistant Director with concurrence from a DAG. In cases with Just Compensation in excess of $500,000, approval of the Secretary is also required.
3.4 If no request is made or response received within the time frames identified, no ADR shall be allowed. If any activity or determination of either party is not performed within the identified time frames during the ADR process, without a written request and agreement for additional time to meet the obligation, the ADR process will be considered canceled by the obliged party.
3.5 Both parties shall have the right to cancel the ADR at any time. However if the ADR review is canceled by the property owner less than 30 days prior to the hearing, they shall be responsible for any costs incurred by DelDOT related to the conducting of the ADR review.
3.6 Within 30 days of agreement between the parties to meet, each party shall submit the name of one Delaware Licensed Real Estate Appraiser that is qualified to appraise the property being acquired, who shall act as a review panel member.
3.7 The parties shall mutually select a third, independent, qualified member for the ADR review panel. If no agreement for a third member is reached, the parties shall request the Board of Realtors for the County the property is located in to appoint a Delaware Licensed Real Estate Broker, or Delaware Licensed Real Estate Appraiser, whose expertise includes the type of property being acquired, to act as the Chief ADR officer. This person shall be compensated for their time at the review as well as any travel in accordance with DelDOT's reimbursement for Fee Appraisers.
3.8 The Chief ADR Officer will act as the lead for the review panel and will be responsible to prepare the final report.
3.9 The date and place of the review shall be arranged between the two parties and the members of the ADR review panel.
3.10 All documentation to be supplied by the parties shall be presented to the ADR officers and the opposing party no less than 15 days prior to the review.
3.11 The members of the ADR review panel shall meet in private to discuss the merits of each party's appraisal and documentation. There will not be any testimony or input required from either party for the review unless requested by the ADR review panel. Copies of any testimony or input required of the parties shall be made available to the opposing party.
3.12 The ADR review panel shall then reach a value conclusion based upon the information provided. A majority vote of the members must agree to approve the final value determination.
3.13 The Chief ADR officer, with assistance from the other members, shall present a report detailing the determination of value as well as the justification for the determination. The amount of detail required is to be determined by the ADR panel members; however, the report must clearly justify the panel's findings and reference any materials, testimony or input used to arrive at the determination.
3.14 The final report shall be transmitted in writing to the parties within 30 days of the review meeting.
3.15 If the ADR is a non-binding review, each party shall have 20 days to accept or reject the ADR determination. If both parties accept, the parties shall proceed to settlement. If either party rejects the determination, the case shall continue the normal eminent domain process.
3.16 The parties shall notify the other party as well as the ADR of their determination in writing.
3.17 Upon final receipt of the ADR report, the ADR review panel shall be dismissed and any compensation will be made to the members.
3.18 The ADR report is considered a protected document and may not be distributed to any party without consent by both parties and the members of the ADR prior to completion of all portions of the real estate transaction or any ancillary activities relating to the real estate transaction.
